Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
What is this?
Less
More
Real Men Real Style Community

13.6k members • Free

Brotherhood Of Scent

8.9k members • Free

Watch Lover | Community

2.7k members • Free

629 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
Sample Storage!
I think I have reached my wits end with my samples. I am SO fortunate that my Sales associates that I regularly work with give me samples so freely of so many different houses, plus the few discovery sets I have purchased on my own. Here is my problem, most samples come in the tiny 2ml decants, some come in folder cards, some come in small boxes. I used to keep them by season in different zip lock bags, but that doesn't store well. I have found that I don't reach for my samples because they aren't organized well, not visually easy to find and decide what to try. My bottles and my 10ml decants are all labeled and in a place that makes it easy to test and grab, but these samples are getting harder and harder to manage. I have made it known to my Sales associates, that moving forward whenever possible I want to get 10mls are ideal, but nothing smaller than 5, with clear labeling that doesn't rub off. That will take a while for sure to move through, What are you all doing to keep your samples organized and in a position to know what you have and grab it easily when you're ready for it? Thanks in advance for all your help and ideas.
Sample Storage!
10 likes • 6d
@Jeffrey Plotka it’s a folder for storing fountain pens. Got mine from Amazon (I have 2 now).
1 like • 5h
@Jeffrey Plotka brilliant! Glad to help. :-)
SOTD: The Most Wanted parfum by Azzarro 01/09/2026
I think this may have been the bottle that convinced me I would collect fragrances. Part of my original comforting holy Trinity. Which included Spicebomb Extreme and SWY Intensley. I guess these warm comforting Winter fragrances are my vibe? TMW parfum landed in 2022 as a denser, more concentrated take on the Wanted family, composed by Michel Girard, Nadège Le Garlantezec, Shyamala Maisondieu, and Roxanne Kirkpatrick. It opens with a sharp, almost electric hit of red ginger, then quickly folds into glowing woody notes that add warmth and structure without turning heavy or resinous. The dry-down is where the bourbon takes over, giving the whole thing a smooth, slightly gourmand finish that stays masculine instead of tipping into pure dessert territory. What makes this one interesting is how cleanly it balances its three main pillars. The ginger keeps things from getting too syrupy, the woods prevent the vanilla from feeling cheap or cloying, and the higher concentration gives it real staying power. I get an easy six to seven hrs on skin with solid projection for the first few. It sits in that sweet-spot between modern designer crowd-pleaser and something a bit more grown-up; the toffee-like warmth that creeps in around the middle adds a quiet richness that works especially well in cooler weather or evening settings without shouting for attention the way some of its sweeter siblings do. The black barrel bottle with its amber-tinted juice just looks the part. Its simple, solid, and recognizably Azzaro. The scent itself delivers on the “most wanted” promise without overcomplicating the formula. It’s not trying to reinvent the wheel; it just refines a familiar spicy-sweet profile into something more focused and wearable. If you like warm, spicy vanillas that still feel sharp and present rather than soft and cuddly, this one earns its place. My Rating 9/10 Scent 3 Longevity 2.5 Sillage 2.5 Would I rebuy? 1
SOTD: The Most Wanted parfum by Azzarro 01/09/2026
5 likes • 7d
These are a gap in my designer collection. Only Azzaro I have is Chrome.
SOTE - By The Fireplace by Maison Margiela
After a pleasant day of sporting A Whiff of Waffle Cone by Imaginary Authors, tonight I'm wearing By The Fireplace by Maison Margiela. Both fragrances are warming and friendly and scratch similar itches, but the Replica scent is more coded towards evening wear. Top Notes: Clove, Pink Pepper, Orange Blossom Absolute Heart Notes: Gaiac Wood, Chestnut, Cade Juniper Base Notes: Vanilla, Cashmeran, Peru Balsam It strikes quite hard from the off with a swirling but cosy smokiness from the clove-and-pepper combo. It's a warming scent, quite welcoming, and this is backed up by the developing chestnut and vanilla gourmand notes. These bring an opulent autumnal holiday vibe, backed with the delicate fir pine backing. It's a Christmas scent, a Christmas scene, a festive fragrance throughout. At an EDT strength, you'd expect the performance to be of secondary importance, but there's nothing lacking here. It hangs around for a good long while, projecting at every step. Of course, it helps that it leans into the most strident of scent profiles, but promising isn't the same as achieving so it's good that it delivers. I particularly enjoy the personal bubble on this scent, as on me at least it hugs hard and lingers long. I love this scent. It's my favourite Replica fragrance by a fair margin, and it's one I return to often as the nights start to lengthen. I had hoped that Jazz Club would also join it on the shelf, but as an ex-smoker that scent comes across more ashtray than speak-easy to my nose. I am currently enjoying the new Lost Eden by the house, maybe that'll be the second bottle I buy from these guys. Rating: 8.5/10. Would I rebuy? Yes. What about you? Which Maison Margiela fragrances stand out in your collections?
SOTE - By The Fireplace by Maison Margiela
0 likes • 7d
@Edward Mooney it’s a lovely fragrance, very evocative.
Brotherhood!!! Plese read and give opinions!!!
There’s been a lot of talk lately about the decline in participation here, so I figured I’d throw my two cents in. For me, I comment when I actually have something to add. If I own the fragrance, have sampled it, smelled it at a counter, know the house, or I’m interested in trying it, I’ll usually jump in. I like comparisons, first impressions, SOTDs with some substance, unpopular opinions, performance talk, clones versus originals, new releases, and anything that can actually turn into a conversation. But I also think the lack of engagement goes a little deeper than the posts themselves. I think people have become too sensitive to criticism and disagreement. A respectful difference of opinion is not disrespect. We are not all going to smell the same thing, like the same thing, or agree on what is better. That is actually where a lot of the learning comes from. I also think some good brothers have left because disagreements turned into resentment instead of just being disagreements. That is unfortunate. You should be able to tell me you completely disagree with my take on a fragrance, explain why, and we both move on. Maybe I even learn something from you. There is also a little selfishness with engagement. Some people want everybody commenting on their posts, but you rarely see them interacting with anyone else’s. If everybody only participates when they are the one posting, then eventually there is no real community. I have also heard people blame the AI bot for some of the decline. I think that is kind of ridiculous. I understand why people do not like the regurgitating and automatic bot engagement. I am actually not a fan of that part myself. But one comment from a bot does not prevent experienced brothers or newcomers from adding their own thoughts. If ten guys want to have a real conversation underneath it, the bot did not stop that. The human engagement is still up to us. Then I hear about the paid portion of the platform. I have not seen anybody kicked out of the Brotherhood because they did not participate in the paid side.
14 likes • 8d
For me, it's not the disagreements and the like that are draining my enthusiasm. I'm more than happy to disagree with anyone then shake their hand and go about my business. For me, it's the silence to literally 95% of the posts I make. I get a few likes, but on average I get zero responses on literally anything I post. I write a detailed and deep review of an uncommon fragrance, and get no responses. I write a snappier review of an old favourite scent, and get no responses. I post pics of my collection, or my new hauls, and get no responses. I suggest some cool interactive ideas to help form connections in the group, and get no responses. Like, yesterday I posted my initial thoughts on Iris Debonair, and got no responses (other than the Antonio Bot)... and then someone else posted their initial thoughts on it an hour or so later, and people were all like "yeah, I love it, I've been wearing it for days, nice post" and so on. When I post in the other Antonio groups, there's plenty of interaction, but here, in the group in which I feel I have the most to offer and discuss? Nothing. I'm more than happy to look inward to work out why my stuff isn't hitting home, but I can't deny that it isn't screwing with my mental health.
What Makes You Comment?
There’s been discussions about the dwindling interaction on this group of late. In the spirit of trying to improve engagement, I have a question: What makes you comment? Me, I generally drop a comment on posts about fragrances that I have some experience in, be that a smell at a counter or a bottle on my shelf. If it’s a scent I’m also excited about trying, I’ll also comment there, basically anything where I can share a personal insight or thought. Or at least I DID when I felt enthused enough to comment here. So… what about you?
6 likes • 9d
@Jon Jacobs Okay cool. But when you DO have time to comment on stuff, what makes you comment on the posts you choose?
1-10 of 629
Craig Stevenson
7
1,441 points to level up
@craig-stevenson-7270
50+ nerd from the UK

Active 2h ago
Joined Jan 21, 2026
Powered by