Yes, can relate, and you can appeal, as well as ask for a waiver, or a lower repayment, but they are each very different. And as Michael states above, try to contact SSA to go over the notice so you understand and can respond based on an INFORMED decision. My husband was sent 2 separate overpayment letters, as well as 1 “we recalculated your benefit to a lower amount” letter, even though both his DWB and SSDI benefit amount and retroactive pay were supposedly miscalculated, although I do not believe this is factual. They have made hundreds —no exaggeration— of mistakes on his claim alone that I have no reason to believe that this is not just another error. We have many times have asked for an explanation and rationale for the overpayment decision AND requested the proper response forms so we could answer within the deadline. No response, other than telling us that the field office has been emailed the requests made by the 1800 agent when we called. Their own policy mandates that they send the right forms and envelopes with the letter, so check and keep trying. Our situation is still unresolved, as we refused to fill out the form that would have accepted fault or responsibility for the overpayment. Keep us posted Scott, and please watch Ed’s lesson on overpayments here in Skool, and PLEASE search the discussions here for “overpayment” to see other posts and answers. Good luck! Beth

Can’t wait to see Dr Ed’s response, or anyone else’s. Great question Ken. Been in a similar position. I believe you have a right to review your file according to comments by Ed on a different post. Did anyone reply DM to this? Beth

Ken, I believe the charge for a copy of your entire file, not just medical documents should not apply, or be waived, if the information is needed for a claim. Same thing for copy of itemized earnings record, fee is not charged if the request or need is part of an ongoing claim.

https://www.skool.com/benefits/start-here?p=a229b49d check out Ed’s post here to a similar situation

The program measures households counting you as sharing everything

Walter, was your original claim for disability, survivor, SSI, or SSDI? Or? And what age were you in July? The denial letter should state the type of benefit they processed, whether or not it is what you intended. Let us know Please. Beth

@Ed Weir wait, now I am more confused. If on SSDI you already have Medicare, right? So at 65 an SSDI recipient can get a Medicare supplement not available under 65. But is it 65 or FRA (67) that SSDI converts to retirement meaning no more CDR or SGA earnings limits, if relevant. Please clarify

@Ed Weir Thanks for that helpful response. Please tell, what is the best simple non adversarial recourse when one has been told No, you cannot apply, repeatedly over many years. Please note that when the claim was finally “taken” we were advised by the 1 800 agent to document this and request an earlier protected filing date. Five months after the claim was started on the phone, we were given a phone appt with a separate agent at the FO, not assigned to the claim, who responded by separate call back to us later that day that “No. You cannot ask for that. Request denied”. The letter later sent documenting that appointment was only about not being eligible for SSI, even though no application for SSI was requested or discussed. How do we fix this issue (as well as several others) that were specifically asked about in the first appeal and were all entirely ignored once the claim was approved. You cannot appeal a closed claim has been the answer, and the attorney hired after the appeal was filed withdrew immediately at initial yes, even before the benefit was calculated. We are stuck. Have studied the POMs need your expert guidance.