Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
What is this?
Less
More
204 contributions to Brotherhood Of Scent
Weekly BOS Member Shoutouts 🔥
Brotherhood, here are a few standout posts from the BOS community this week. 👏 Big shoutout to @Lon Chaneyfield for “FRAGRANCE MYTHS: FACT VS. FICTION” and a clear breakdown of the role skin chemistry really plays in fragrance. It created an informed, high-value discussion that helps members evaluate fragrance advice more confidently. Post: https://www.skool.com/bos/fragrance-myths-fact-vs-fiction 👏 Shoutout to @Robert Sheard for “SOTD – Parfums de Marly Herod” and a thoughtful update from his continued exploration of the fragrance. His detailed wear experience gave fellow members useful perspective on revisiting and evaluating samples over time. Post: https://www.skool.com/bos/sotd-parfums-de-marly-herod-85af7970 👏 Shoutout to @Tim Dennis for “What makes a fragrance a 10/10 for you?” and asking the community a great question about personal standards in fragrance. It encouraged members to think beyond simple ratings and share what truly makes a scent exceptional. Post: https://www.skool.com/bos/what-makes-a-fragrance-a-1010-for-you 👏 Shoutout to @Carl Ronny Birkeland for “Why People Collect Perfume: The Psychology of Accepting Less” and bringing a reflective perspective to fragrance collecting. It invited members to consider the motivations and habits behind building a collection. Post: https://www.skool.com/bos/why-people-collect-perfume-the-psychology-of-accepting-less 👏 Shoutout to @Renato Carotti for “SOTD: I Am King by Sean John - Day 374” and keeping up an impressive daily fragrance-sharing habit. Consistent posts like this give the community plenty of real wear experiences to learn from.
2 likes • 10h
Gentleman, your knowledge and experience enrich this little hobby/addiction of mine. Keep it up
FRAGRANCE MYTHS: FACT VS. FICTION
Part 1: Skin Chemistry Completely Changes a Fragrance. THE MYTH: "Every fragrance smells completely different on everybody because of skin chemistry." THE REALITY: Skin chemistry matters, but it generally doesn't completely rewrite a fragrance's composition. We've all heard someone say, "That smells totally different on my skin than it does on yours." There's some truth to that, but we need to understand what's actually happening. A fragrance is built around a formula. Its aromatic materials don't suddenly become entirely different ingredients because two people have different skin chemistry. What can change is how those materials behave. Skin temperature, moisture, natural oils, and individual skin characteristics can influence evaporation, diffusion, and how certain notes are perceived. One person's skin may emphasize sweetness, while another's may bring out woods, spices, or musks. Here's something else to consider. Our noses aren't identical either. We have different sensitivities to individual aroma chemicals. Sometimes what we attribute to skin chemistry is actually a difference in how we perceive certain materials. This is also why I encourage testing fragrances on skin, but I use cotton rounds as well. A cotton round gives me a relatively neutral surface to follow the fragrance's development without the same influence of skin. It helps me understand the basic structure of the fragrance, including its opening, heart, and drydown. More importantly, a cotton round can help you determine whether you even like a particular scent profile in the first place. If you're testing a fragrance with a heavy leather, oud, iris, amber, or gourmand profile, you can get a good idea of whether that style appeals to you before committing valuable skin space to it. It's especially useful when you're testing multiple fragrances. You can set the cotton rounds aside, revisit them over several hours, and experience how the scent develops. But there's an important distinction: A cotton round can tell you whether you like the scent profile. Your skin tells you how that fragrance actually wears on you.
8 likes • 2d
D&Gs light blue intense (at least the old formulation) seems to be one that doesn't agree with my skin. I did a little digging and others had a similar experience. Its a great frag, but on my skin it has one note that registers in my minds as Hawaiian pizza and soda vomit at a child's birthday party. After looking into it, there's a number of folks who also detect one sour note when on skin. A "rotten lemon" note is usually how its described. Out of all the fragrances ive worn, its the only one that I've had that sort of negative change when on skin.
Nusuk Al Mukhtalif Signature
Still working through first wearings from my last shipment... today I try my first Nusuk fragrance ever, Al Mukhtalif Signature. Packaging: I think the bottle is unique and kinda cool. The magnetic cap is extremely weak, which is actually a good thing. It's impossible to lift the bottle by the cap and accidentally drop it. Juice: This isn't a clone of anything, but it's a classic oud/rose scent done perfectly. Rich, dark, and resinous, with a touch of sweet/spicy. For some reason many compare this to LV's Ombré Nomade (which I really like), but it's only about 70% similar. Al Mukhtalif Signature has zero smokiness, a bit of citrus and vanilla, and is much less animalic than Ombré Nomade. I could just as easily compare it to Shaghaf Oud... if you removed the sweet praline and saffron notes and added more woods, amber, musk, and citrus. What I'm saying is, it's its own thing. Buyers beware: Al Mukhtalif and Al Mukhtalif Signature are two VERY different scents with nothing in common except the house, name, and bottle design. (I bought both. We'll talk about the other one soon.) Performance: Outstanding. I sprayed it on paper days ago and it's still there! On skin, it's a 10hr+ kinda frag. (Not as strong as Shaghaf Oud, but close.) Season: Definitely fall/winter. Value: I paid only $31.50 CAD for my bottle. It's one of the best value buys of my life. Parfumo users have this rated at 7.5 overall, but only a handful of users have voted on it. Fragantica has a more votes, with 76 users giving it a 4.13/5. Its not a very well known or popular fragrance. For me, this is my new favourite oud scent. 9/10 overall
Nusuk Al Mukhtalif Signature
2 likes • 2d
@Akash Purohit it is!
1 like • 2d
I forgot to mention, concentration is extrait de parfum
The Extraits: 3 for 3, going for 4
Last year I picked up Aether and did a side-by-side with PDM's Greenley. Aether was such a good clone that I decided not to buy Greenley, which I only liked, not loved. Then I picked up Atlantis. Room 1015's Wavechild is great, but it's only something I'd wear a few times a year. Another side-by-side, and I passed on Wavechild and gave the rest of my decant to a lady friend. Last week I bought Chaos, and I still dont know what it's a clone of. I thought it would be Room 1015's Cherry Punk, but i have a decant of that, and it's not even close. It's a leather/cherry frag that's just really good! So today I ordered the final fragrance in the series, Irida. Inspired by Tom Ford's Electric Cherry. It looks like a very feminine cherry/floral scent...its pink. After going 3 for 3 with this line, I have to try it out. So far, nothing but bangers. I like the bottle design too. It adds some colour to the collection. Great value scents from French Avenue. Which ones have you tried, and how have they worked for you? (Note: I asked AI what Chaos is a clone of and it wasnt sure, but suggested Cuir InfraRouge by Maison Crivelli as the possible inspiration. Anyone do side by side testing?)
The Extraits: 3 for 3, going for 4
2 likes • 2d
@D Rub i barely wear wavechild, but i love putting it on a girl im with and enjoying the scent trail she leaves. Its worth it just for that. Hmmm... I should write a future post about using your perfume addiction to help pick up and retain women.
PDM - Kalan
On a 45 degree morning and warming into the 60's this one just seemed right. It is a very polarizing scent, but I love it!
PDM - Kalan
7 likes • 2d
Big fan of Kalan. My sample is almost empty. A full bottle will be bought eventually.
5 likes • 2d
@Jeffrey Plotka I was hoping to get a bottle of what reviewers say is the best kalan clone, Kalos by Maison Alhambra, before I paid PDM prices. Its been out of stock all year and I love Kalan enough to justify the purchase, so im giving up doing my own side by side comparison for now. Have you had a chance to compare the 2?
1-10 of 204
Christopher Lavis
7
2,728 points to level up
@christopher-lavis-7718
Christian, Father, Railroader, Canadian, Professional Ass-Kicker.

Active 4h ago
Joined Feb 18, 2025
Powered by