When we let buyers bid on leads instead of paying a set price, I figured the cap was a formality. Minimum bid was $200, you went up in $50 steps, and we capped it at $1,000 cuz nobody was going to pay that for one lead. In some counties buyers hit the cap. We didn't get smarter about pricing. We just stopped telling the buyer what the lead was worth and let the ones who knew their own numbers tell us. It was second-price too, so the winner paid based on the next highest bid, not their own max. That took the games out of it. People bid what a lead was actually worth to them. Most agencies price off what they think the client will tolerate. The client who knows his close rate and his average job will usually pay more than you'd ever have the nerve to ask. How are you setting your price right now, off your costs or off what one customer is worth to the client?