User
Write something
Pinned
Creative Force Dispatch
THE CREATIVE FORCE Harvard's Center for Digital Thriving named this week's problem: "AI is making student learning invisible to teachers." Offering Maryland undergraduates an AI tutor pulled them away from their own courses. Our defenses shrink the work further; as Jennifer Taback writes, "we have narrowed assessment to what we can proctor." But mathematics is a creative act you can only judge if you can see it: a question posed and lived with, the way young mathematicians took four papers to crack Graham's 1971 conjecture. So by June, where will the math we grade actually happen? THE FIVE 1. [Research] EdWorkingPapers: The Effects of Course-Integrated AI Tutoring on Student Performance and Engagement: A Randomized University Trial In a University of Maryland randomized trial, sections given a university-provided tutor built on OpenAI's GPT-4o earned final grades 0.37 standard deviations below other sections of the same course, though only about 15% of students ever used it (working paper, not yet peer-reviewed). Before any AI rollout in math, ask what it will replace. 2. [Report] Harvard's Center for Digital Thriving: An AI Policy Isn't a Playbook Among teachers who had faced an AI dilemma, 74% described something about cheating, and the side effect is perverse: "Some students deliberately underperform to avoid being flagged." In math, suspicion teaches students to hide exactly the thinking we're trying to grow. 3. [Essay] Terence Tao's blog: What does the advent of powerful AI models mean for mathematicians like me? Bowdoin's Jennifer Taback resents AI for pushing her assessments into timed classrooms, since without graduate student help, oral exams are "impractical at the scale of my teaching." Yet AI is also the research colleague her small department can't provide: a double bind teaching-heavy departments will recognize. 4. [Policy] CalMatters: Student math scores are abysmal. A new California law requires early testing for skill SB 1067 will screen every California K–2 student on counting, quantities, and number recognition starting in 2028, with no new money attached. The state's largest teachers union opposed it, arguing teachers already know who is struggling; the real test is whether screening changes what happens next. 5. [News] Quanta: Mathematicians Harness Randomness To Crack a 55-Year-Old Conjecture Ronald Graham asked in 1971 whether any set of nonzero numbers on a prime-hour clock can be ordered so every running total is different; four papers by young mathematicians now prove it for every large enough prime. Noah Kravitz's motive, "it's embarrassing for humanity that we don't know this," is the creative force no proctored test measures.
Poll
1 member has voted
Pinned
The Uncomfortable Truth of Teaching Mathematics
The Books Became My Mentors with Dr. Venessa Palmer. Here is the link to the episode: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/books-became-my-mentors-dr-kevin-berkopes-lrjbc
1
0
The Uncomfortable Truth of Teaching Mathematics
Pinned
The Uncomfortable Truth of Teaching Mathematics
You Never Get Out with Dr. Ayanna Perry. Here is a link to the episode: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/you-never-get-out-dr-kevin-berkopes-qlq5c
1
0
The Uncomfortable Truth of Teaching Mathematics
Nobody Knew That
Eric was formed by having room. He was given a level of autonomy in his first year that essentially no first-year teacher receives today, and he used it to become the kind of educator who is still, twenty-six years later, describing seventh-grade lesson planning with real pleasure. The room made him. He is now the person removing the room. And he is right to. Full link to the article here: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/nobody-knew-dr-kevin-berkopes-ytitc
Nobody Knew That
Creative Force Dispatch: A Correct Solution the Student Can't Explain. What's it Worth?
New format: five reads and one question we answer together. Vote, tell us why, and next week's Dispatch opens with how you voted and the top comment. Research mathematics just ran into a problem every math teacher knows. OpenAI's Navier–Stokes proof appears to be correct, but experts say it "doesn't teach us much." The first 3D "Einstein" tile was, in its finder's words, "found by Astra, not me." Every teacher has graded that paper: the right answer, with nobody home behind it. Harvard's PhD summit reaches for the teacher's fix: have students defend it out loud. The Khanmigo study shows the catch: students walk away when the tutor asks them to think. THE FIVE [Radio · 4 min] NPR: AI solved one of math's hardest problems. Humanity learned nothing (so far) OpenAI's 166-page Navier–Stokes proof passes a computer check, yet the mathematicians reading it say they can't learn much: "The paper is not written for humans." It's the clearest case yet that a proof and an explanation are different things. [News] Quanta: Software developer finds first 3D "einstein" tile An Athens software developer used OpenAI's GPT-6 Astra to find Chair44, a single shape that fills space but never repeats. He says he understands the intuition, "not the mathematics of it." Amateur discovery changed the meaning, and so did checking: an expert had to cut the 61-page paper to eight pages so others could follow it. [Report] Harvard CMSA: Recommendations of the Summit on PhD Math Education in the Age of AI Twenty-four senior mathematicians propose that a PhD "should not be awarded primarily on the basis of the text of the dissertation," but on a defense that demands complete mastery. Read "dissertation" as "homework," and it's a blueprint for assessment in any math classroom. It's a first draft, and they want feedback.
Poll
1 member has voted
1-30 of 97
powered by
Math as a Creative Force
skool.com/math-as-a-creative-force-1087
Where mathematics becomes a sensory, creative practice—evolving perception, meaning-making, and human judgment together.
Build your own community
Bring people together around your passion and get paid.
Powered by